This is an incomplete list, which may never be able to satisfy certain standards for completeness. You can help by expanding it.
In the history of the European colonization of North America, the term "Indian massacre" was often used to describe either mass killings of Europeans by indigenous people of the North American continent ("Indians") or mass killings of indigenous peoples by Europeans (or occasionally mass killings between different groups of indigenous peoples, as in the Cutthroat Gap Massacre). In theory, massacre applied to the killing of civiliannoncombatants or to the summary execution of prisoners-of-war. In practice, the label was often haphazardly applied, rarely without bias, and was sometimes used to describe an overwhelming (though lawful) military defeat. Similarly, massacres were sometimes mislabeled "battles" in an attempt to give legitimacy to what would today be considered a war crime. Some incidents remain disputed as to whether they were massacres or battles.
Determining how many people died in these massacres overall is difficult. In the book The Wild Frontier: Atrocities during the American-Indian War from Jamestown Colony to Wounded Knee, amateur historian William M. Osborn sought to tally every recorded atrocity in the area that would eventually become the continental United States, from first contact (1511) to the closing of the frontier (1890), and determined that 9,156 people died from atrocities perpetrated by Native Americans, and 7,193 people died from retaliations perpetrated by whites. Osborn defines an atrocity as the murder, torture, or mutilation of civilians, the wounded, and prisoners. Different definitions would obviously produce different totals.[1]
"He...has endeavoured to bring on the inhabitants of our frontiers, the merciless Indian Savages, whose known rule of warfare, is an undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions."
List of massacres
This is a listing of some of the events reported then or referred to now as "Indian massacres":
Hernando de Soto’s expedition ambushed by Choctaws[2] burned down palisaded town of Mabila and killed approx. 2,500 in a battle lasting several hours.[3]
Duncan, E., Hernando de Soto, pp. 376-384; Steele, I., Warpaths, p. 15.
In retaliation for the killing of 11 Spanish soldiers, Juan de Oñate led punitive expedition to slaughter the natives in a three-day battle at the Acoma mesa. Approx. 800 dead. Spain's King later punished Oñate for his excesses.[4]
Powhatans (Pamunkey) killed 347 English men, women and children throughout the Virginia colony, almost one-third of the English population of Jamestown colony.
The English poisoned the wine at a "peace conference" with Powhatan leaders, killing ca. 200 and another 50 by hand in retaliation for the Jamestown Massacre.
English colonists commanded by John Underhill, with Mohegan and Narragansett allies, launched a night attack a large Pequot village on the Mystic River in what is now Connecticut, burning the inhabitants alive and killing the survivors, with about 600-700 killed.
In 1643 an Iroquois tribe, the Mohawks, attacked a band of Wappingers. The Wappingers fled to Manhattan Island seeking protection of Dutch governor, who had hired John Underhill. The sleeping village was slaughtered with about 80 deaths, and the group was exterminated.
Pueblo warriors killed 380 Spanish settlers, counting men, women and children, and drove the other Spaniards from New Mexico. By 1690s sedentary Pueblo farmers wanted the Spanish to come back to protect them against Apache and Navajo raiders.
Fifteen hundred Mohawk warriors attacked the small settlement of Lachine, New France and killed more than ninety of the village's three-hundred seventy-five French residents.
In retaliation to the rumored murder of a captured Stockbridge man and detainment of Rogers Ranger Captain Quinten Kennedy - Major Robert Rogers led a party of approximately 150 English regulars, volenteers and Mohican Tribe Natives into the village of Odanak where reports of up to 30 deaths, amung them women and children, have been confirmed via conflicting reports.
Bruchac M., Reading Abenaki Traditions and European Records of Rogers Raid, p.3-4[8]
Following a battle with rebel defenders of Forty Fort, Iroquois allies of the Loyalist forces hunted and killed those who fled, then tortured to death those who surrendered.
Konstantin, P., This day in North American Indian history, p. 181
The home of Johannes Dietz, Berne, New York, was attacked by Indians during the Revolution. Johannes, his wife, their daughter-in-law (wife of their son, Capt. William Dietz), four children of their son's family, and a servant girl were killed and scalped.
Priest, Josiah, "Stories of the Revolution", first published 1836
Nearly 100 non-combatant Christian Delaware (Lenape) Indians, mostly women and children, were killed with hammer blows to the head by Pennsylvania militiamen.
Konstantin, Phil, This day in North American Indian history, p. 57
John Corbly, whose wife and five children were massacred in western Pennsylvania
[Daughters of the American Revolution Magazine By Daughters of the American Revolution, Published by R.R. Bowker Co., 1925 Item notes: v.59 1925 Jan-Jun page234]
The murder of 60-100 Pomo people on Bo-no-po-ti island near Clear Lake, (Lake Co., California), by Nathaniel Lyon and his U. S. Army detachment, in retribution for the killing of two Clear Lake settlers who had been abusing and murdering Pomo people. (The Island Pomos had no connections to the enslaved Pomos). This incident led to a general mass killing of native people all over Northern California.
Letter, Brevet Capt. N. Lyon to Major E.R.S. Canby, May 22, 1850, cited in Heizer, Robert F., The Destruction of California Indians, pp. 244-246.
1853
Before December 31
"Ox" incident
Unreported number of Indians were killed in the Four Creeks area (Tulare Co., California) in "our little difficulty" and "the chastisement they have received"
Letter, Bvt. 2nd Lieut. John Nugens to Lieut T. Wright, Dec. 31, 1853, quoted in Heizer, pp. 12-13.
Eighteen of the 20 members of the Alexander Ward party were killed by Shoshoni Indians while traveling on the Oregon Trail in western Idaho. This event led to the eventual abandonment of Fort Boise and Fort Hall, in favor of the use of military escorts. [2][3]
Michno, Gregory, Encyclopedia of Indian Wars, pp. 28-29
1855
January 22
Klamath River massacres
In retaliation for the murder of 6 white people and stealing of some cattle, "whites" commenced a "war of extermination against the Indians" in Humboldt Co., California
Crescent City Herald, quoted in Sacramento newspaper, cited in Heizer, pp. 35-36.
About 188 Wiyot Indians, mostly women and children, were killed by white settlers in Humboldt County, California, during one of three simultaneous assaults on the Wiyot [4]
Michno, Gregory, Encyclopedia of Indian Wars, pp. 72-73; Heizer
Several massacres of native encampments by American settlers exterminated the 200 members of the Yahi tribe, such as the first in 1865 (74 killed), the 1866 Three Knolls (40 killed) and Dry Camp (33 killed) massacres, ending with the Kingsley Cave/Morgan Camp massacre (30 killed) in 1871. The Yahi were Ishi’s tribe.
Cook, S., The Conflict between the California Indian and White Civilization.
Led by ex-Tucson mayor, William Oury, a vigilante band from Tucson slaughtered Apache women and children while the men were doing their spring planting. More than 100 dead.
Northern Cheyenne under Dull Knife attempted to escape from confinement in Fort Robinson, Nebraska; about fifty survived. The remains of those killed were repatriated in 1994.
Michno, Gregory, Encyclopedia of Indian Wars, pp. 322-323
Indian Agent Nathan Meeker and 10 others killed by Utes; likewise a military unit is ambushed and 13 killed and 43 wounded. The Beginning of the Ute War
^ In all, the massacred were twenty-six soldiers, two officers (Captain Wells and Surgeon Van Voorhees), two women and twelve children, and twelve trappers and settlers hired as scouts.