The Ilyushin 86 is a medium-range wide-body jet airliner designed and tested by the Ilyushin design bureau in the 1970s, certificated by the Soviet aircraft industry during the 1970s and 1980s and manufactured jointly by the USSR and Poland. It was the first Soviet wide-body airliner and the world's second four-engined wide-body. Emerging during the Brezhnev stagnation, the Il-86 made Soviet technical and organisational decline obvious with its obsolescent engines and unduly prolonged development which prevented it entering service for the Moscow Olympics, as had been intended. Only 106 were built and only three were exported. The type was used overwhelmingly by Aeroflot and, after the collapse of the USSR, by successor post-Soviet airlines. It gained recognition as a safe and reliable machine which did what had been asked of it. By 2008, more than half of all Il-86s had been retired.
Design and developmentBackgroundIn the mid-1960s the USA and Western Europe planned airliners seating significantly more than the then-maximum of about 200 passengers: airbuses in contemporaneous parlance. The Soviet leadership wanted to match them with its own aerobus (Russian: аэробус). Though the propaganda motive was immensely powerful in Soviet policymaking, the USSR also had a pressing practical need for such an airliner. Aeroflot was growing very rapidly and expected to carry over 100 million passengers a year within a decade. First to respond to the need was OKB-153, the bureau led by Oleg Antonov, which proposed a 724-seat version of the An-22 airlifter[1]. This did not go ahead due to fears that it would be old-fashioned and because the Kiev-based bureau had been too closely associated with the deposed Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev[2][3]. ConceptAccommodating the 250 or more passengers envisaged for aerobuses called for ingenuity: many Soviet airports had small terminals and rebuilding them was prohibitive. To resolve the problem, Soviet aircraft industry research institutes elaborated a concept of passengers loading and unloading their luggage into and from baggage holds in the aerobus as they boarded and disembarked: "the luggage at hand" system (Russian: система "багаж с собой"; transliterated: sistyema "bagazh s soboy"). Airbus Industrie studied such arrangements in the mid-1970s[4]; Lockheed implemented a similar system into the L-1011 TriStar in 1973 at the request of Pacific Southwest Airlines (PSA)[5]. Many Soviet airports also had weak surfaces and the aerobus had to match the ground loadings of existing airliners. This called for a complex and heavy multi-wheel landing gear[6]. In October 1967, the Soviet government approved a general specification for an aerobus drawn up by the Ministry of Civil Aviation (Aeroflot). This called for a seating capacity of 350, a range of 3600 kilometres/1900 nautical miles with a 40-tonne payload or up to 5800km/3100nm with most seats taken but no freight. The airliner had to be able to operate from smaller regional and local airports (classified as Klass "B" and "V" [Russian: класс "Б", "В"] or "Class B/C" by the Soviets), with runway lengths of up to 2600 metres/8500 feet[7]. In the second half of the 1960s, OKB-240 (as the Ilyushin bureau was formally known) was restoring the political positions it had lost (along with Yakovlev, in favour of Tupolev and Antonov) amid the anti-Stalinism of the Khrushchev era[8] and was well placed to secure design of the Soviet aerobus. Indeed, when the Soviet cabinet's defence industry committee progressed the Aeroflot specification on 8 September 1969 onto the preliminary project (Russian: аванпроект; transliterated: avanproyekt) stage[9], it entrusted it to Ilyushin. The bureau received specific operational requirements for the aerobus on 22 February 1970. Having won the political battle for the prestige project, the bureau now faced four technical challenges: configuration (layout), powerplant, automation (avionics) and manufacturing capacity. Conceptual developmentIlyushin began its preliminary aerobus project in late 1969. Initially, this involved assessing the development potential of existing hardware. This included "stretched" versions of the Il-62, double-deck or "two fuselages side-by-side" developments of it, as well as civilianised versions of the Il-76. Eventually, the bureau moved to all-new designs. In a philosophical shift, it also embraced high-technology in contrast to the "appropriate technology approach" it had taken in developing the Il-62. Thus, the Il-86 would have powered controls, complex high-lift devices and advanced automation enabling fewer flightdeck crew.[10] An early version of the avanproyekt was shown to the Soviet leadership at an exhibition of civil aviation novelties held at the Vnukovo-2 Airport near Moscow on 17 May 1971[11][12][13]. A scale model bore the true designation of "Il-86" (Russian: Ил-86, transliterated "Il vosem’desyat' shest'"). The model showed the "self-loading" concept with integral boarding stairs and below-deck luggage stores in addition to a below-deck midships galley. It had a twin-aisle interior with nine-abreast seating in a "3-3-3" layout. Ilyushin considered it politic to make the interior wider (6.08m/239in) than any airliner except the Boeing 747[14]. Configuration: The difference between the 1971 model and the eventual Il-86 was that the model looked like an Il-62. At that time, the clean-winged, rear-engined, T-tailed configuration of the Il-62 was favoured by TsAGI for airliners. The BAC Three-Eleven[15]and BAC/CASA/MBB Europlane[16] projects had similar configurations. The configuration of heavy jet aircraft had become a sensitive issue in the USSR. Aircraft designer Leonid Selyakov[17] states: "The configuration of the В-47, taken on strength by the US Air Force ... brought forth a veritable storm of critical opinions from [Soviet] aviation scientists. Responsible TsAGI officials and industry leaders robustly called that aircraft 'utter nonsense' (similar opinions were expressed of the Boeing 747)." Ardent controversy was not unknown in Western aeronautical circles[18] but this degree of entrenched doctrinal intransigence was typical most of all of Soviet ideology which was accustomed to the idea that there had to be a single scientifically-correct solution for every problem[19]. Ilyushin therefore stressed that it had first in the world adopted podded engines suspended from pylons beneath and ahead of the wing, on the experimental Il-22 four-engined jet bomber of 1946 (first use of this designation)[20]. Having thus been presented as indigenously Soviet, the Il-86's ultimate configuration could at last appear in public in 1973, six years after publication of the aerobus specification and four years after the bureau had received the design assignment[21][22]. Six-light flightdeck glazing came soon afterwards. Powerplant: The main problem facing the Il-86 project was the lack of a suitable engine. This problem was never resolved. The USA and the UK had turbofans with bypass ratios of 4 or 5 to 1. The first Soviet large turbofan, the Lotarev D-18T, did not appear before the mid-1980s[23]. The Soloviev D-30, originally intended for the Il-86, was the most advanced Soviet civil aeroengine. It had a bypass ratio of 2.4 to 1 and aerodynamic clamshell thrust reversers. It failed to attain the required thrust, however: "... only after the lapse of three years that were spent on preparing the advanced development project did it become clear that these engines would not provide the necessary take-off performance"[24]. The less-advanced Kuznetsov NK-8 series engine, adopted on 26 March 1975, had a bypass ratio of 1.15 to 1 and drag-inducing grilles over its cascade thrust reversers. Both these engines had high specific fuel consumptions and were noisy. Being ultimate developments of smaller engines, they could not offer any prospect of growth to the Il-86. Avionics: The appropriate/intermediate technology principles to which most Soviet airliners before the Il-86 had been designed meant that they had typically five-member flight crews. The design and entry into service in 1972 of the Tu-154, an airliner built to high technology principles, showed that Soviet science was lagging in the avionics which removed the need for a navigator and radio operator. A programme of avionics development was thus mounted to enable the Il-86 to operate in most weathers with a three-member flight crew. While it was successful, its outcome only matched the level of Western technology of the late 1960s. Manufacture: The shortage of manufacturing facilities for the Il-86 constituted a problem from the outset: "The rapid modernisation of the Soviet Air Force ... has left limited scope for the expansion of commercial production ... the lack of production capacity is being remedied partly by ... international cooperation"[25]. Interest in acquiring foreign technology: Because of the intractability of the powerplant (and to an extent the avionics and manufacturing capacity) issues, the Soviets tried to acquire foreign technology. Before the Boeing 747 had flown, a Ministry of Civil Aviation delegation visited Boeing and received a series of detailed sales presentations on the type lasting three days. At the 1971 Paris Salon, Ilyushin bureau head Genrikh Novozhilov and Boeing's Joe Sutter arranged an informal technology trade-off. Over supper in a Paris restaurant, the Soviet side ceded information on its titanium technology to the Americans, while the latter, "sketching on the tablecloth," ceded information on "the structural and aerodynamic amity of the aeroelastic wing"[26]. Helped by the détente between the two superpowers at the time, on March 11, 1974, a Lockheed L-1011 TriStar arrived in Moscow for three days of sales presentations and demonstrations[27][28]. The TriStar matched the Il-86 in size and performance and was able to offer the self-loading luggage concept. The American airliner was widely regarded as the technological leader of the period and had development potential. Negotiations to buy 30 TriStars and licence-produce up to 100 more each year in a new factory employing 80,000 people[25] continued until mid-1976[29]. They collapsed as US President Jimmy Carter made human rights a US policy factor. The TriStar was also listed by the Coordinating Committee as embodying advanced technology banned from potential enemies. At the same time, the US Department of Commerce vetoed export of 12 General Electric CF6-50 engines ordered by the USSR for planned long range versions of the Il-86[30]. In the 1980s, there were moves to fit the Il-86 with RB211-22 engines[31]. Designated Il-86V, this would have had a range of over 9000km/4860nm and/or increased payload. A "stretched" 450-seater Il-86V was also projected, to be powered by RB211-524G engines. Amid the disintegration of the Soviet economy these ideas did not progress. In 1991, there were moves to fit the Il-86 with Franco-American CFM56-5C2 engines[32]. Finances precluded progress. In 1995, International Aero Engines offered the V2500 engine for retrospective fitting on the Il-86. No development emerged, though five operators had wanted to re-engine 25 aircraft[33][34]. Design, testing and certificationThe design process at Ilyushin was managed by Sergey Ilyushin's successor as head of the bureau, Genrikh Novozhilov. The timescale announced at the time envisaged first flight in 1976 and service entry in time for the Moscow Olympics in 1980. The prototype flew at Khodynka airfield (where Ilyushin's experimental factory was) on 22 December 1976 (Soviet airliners often flew before the close of the calendar year due to the requirements of Five-Year Plans). At that time, it was learned that the type had a patented energy-efficient deicing system which delivered electromagnetic pulses to parts of the airframe prone to icing[35][36]. The system used 500 times less energy than conventional deicers[37]. The initial test programme was flown by Ilyushin staff, ending two months ahead of schedule on October 20th, 1978. (According to a faster schedule, announced at the time of the first flight, Ilyushin tests were to end in time for the 60th anniversary of the October Revolution, on November 7th, 1977[38].) Initial certification flying by pilots independent of Ilyushin ended on June 6th, 1977. State acceptance trials began on April 24th, 1979 and ended on 24 December 1980. They produced no evidence of shortcomings and certification by Gosaviaregistr SSSR [the USSR State Aviation Registry] was attained, under certificate number 10-86[39]. The service-entry deadline of summer 1980, announced by Minister of Civil Aviation Boris Bugayev in 1977[40] had passed, however, and the Il-86 missed the prestige Moscow Olympics. Overall development of the Il-86 occupied over a decade. The undue length of this period was due to the sensitivity of the airliner's configuration, problems with its powerplant, prolonged avionics development and the low priority assigned to civil as opposed to military aircraft[41]. Moreover, in its early stages, the Il-86 programme was "fall-back insurance" in case US airliner imports failed. Certificating the Il-86 to the very demanding set of Soviet and Comecon standards called NLGS-2 also delayed progress; it was the first Soviet aircraft to undergo a full certification programme since certification was introduced in the USSR in 1967 and made mandatory five years later[42]. Undeveloped versions: On June 26th, 1972, a long-range version of the Il-86, the Il-86D (for Russian: "дальный"; transliterated: "dal’niy"; meaning "long-range"), was ordered into development by the Soviet cabinet. Design was completed in June 1976. The Il-86D would have had a marginally extended wing span, carried additional fuel, and had a range of some 8500km/4600nm. Later announcements stated that the version was to have new high bypass ratio engines, 147,500kg/325,000lb empty weight, 300,000kg/660,000lb maximum take-off weight, fuel capcaity of some 150,000kg/330,000lb, wing area of 325m2/5300 sq ft, and a range of 10,200km/5500nm. This version (also known as Il-86V) evolved into the Il-96. A "minimum-change" development of the Il-86 which was tested in the 1980s but not adopted was a high-density 450 seat version with ten-abreast seating in a 3-4-3 configuration with reduced seat pitch[43]. MarketingIl-86 provision to Aeroflot did not constitute a sale; rather, it was part of the Soviet state's centralised supply and allocation system. It was coordinated by government offices called Gosplan and Gossnab which controlled the entirety of planning and distribution processes in the USSR (except the black market). As part of a similar supply provision, Lot was allocated four Il-86s as barter for component manufacture. That airline deferred deliveries, which had been cancelled by 1987[44]. Selling the Il-86 commercially (which under the Soviet system meant solely exports) was the job of the Soviet foreign trade organisation V/O Aviaeksport. The compartmentalisation of a design bureau, acting like naval architects designing an aeroplane, a separate factory constructing it and a separate organisation selling it, was seen as diluting responsibility[45]. The Il-86 prototype was displayed at the Paris Salon International de l'Aéronautique in 1977. It was noted that its interior used patented fire-resistant materials and hydraulics employed a fire-resistant fluid[46]. At that time a version without the "luggage at hand" system was offered, seating 375 or alternatively weighing 3000kg/6600lb less and having longer range. This version offered 7 per cent lower seat-mile operational costs[47]. The type was again displayed at Paris in 1979, 1981, 1983 and 1985, the Farnborough Air Show in 1984 and other world air events. On Tuesday 22 September 1981, an Il-86 flown by Commander G Volokhov and Second Pilot A Tyuryumin set Fédération Aéronautique Internationale records for flying payloads of 35, 40, 45, 50, 55, 60 and 65 tonnes over a 2000km closed circuit at an average of 975.3km/h[48]. Two days later, the same crew and machine set FAI records for flying payloads of 30, 35, 40, 45, 50, 55, 60, 65, 70, 75 and 80-tonne payloads over a 1000km closed circuit at an average of 962km/h[49]. Of these 18 records, one was broken by a Tu-144 in 1983, five were superseded or discontinued and 12 still stood in mid-2008. In 1982 the type made a sales call in Bulgaria, followed by calls in 1983 in Hungary and Czechoslovakia. The calls appeared to have been hastily arranged[50]. Very little solid information was given to the potential customers: "constructor Novosilov side-stepped all questions [on fuel consumption] ... [the] chief pilot ... provided a measure of veiled explanation: 'The consumption of the Il-86 is not higher than that of the Il-18,' he said." While welcomed as “proof of friendship with the USSR”[51], these calls failed to attract orders. Observers tacitly noted that the aircraft marked a 10/15-year lag by Soviet civil aviation compared with the West. The sole export order for the Il-86 − and the sole commercial transactions involving factory-built rather than secondhand examples − was by China Xinjiang Airlines which bought three aircraft in 1990. The rest of the manufacturing run was allocated by Aeroflot region and Soviet Air Force unit as follows (in order of first acceptance): the Vnukovo Aviation Entreprise, 21; the TsUMVS Administration of International Air Communications centred on Sheremetyevo Airport, 22; the Tashkent Air Enterprise, 9; the Sheremetyevo Air Enterprise, 10; the Pulkovo Air Enterprise, 8; the Alma-Ata Air Enterprise, 8; the Chkalovsky Soviet Air Force Base 8 ADON (or 8th Special Purposes Aviation Division), 4; the Kol'tsovo Air Enterprise, 6; the Tolmachevo Air Enterprise, 6; the Erevan Air Enterprise, 2; the Yemelyanovo Air Enterprise, 3[52]. ManufactureOn the Soviet side, the Ministry of Aircraft Manufacture ("MAP," "Minaviaprom") Factory 64 at Voronezh (today VASO) was tasked with building more than half of the Il-86 and of assembling the airliner[53]. However, capacity there was insufficient. Therefore, the Polish aircraft industry was involved in the Il-86 project from the outset. The arrangement was much not a subcontract; rather, it involved significant technology transfer to Poland to enable it to meet its assigned role: PZL Amalgamation Mielec factory Director Jerzy Belczak said it involved “… a radical retooling of our enterprise” involving “over 50 new processes”[54]. Observers noted that "work on the Il-86 will bring Poland's ... WSK-Mielec to a new level of capability ... in the manufacturing processes involved with an aircraft of this size, including titanium structures, chemical milling and the machining of integral panels"[55]. By the 1980s, Mielec was planned to produce half of the Il-86[56], including its entire wing, and also to work on Il-86 developments (“Now we are preparing to manufacture units for the next model of the Il wide-body plane,” according to Belczak[57] ). From May 1977, the Polish factory manufactured entire empennages including tailplanes and the fin, all control surfaces, high-lift devices and engine pylons for the Il-86, representing "about 16 per cent of these aircraft"[58]. As labour and political unrest spread in Poland from 1980, the Voronezh factory retained wing manufacture. Five aircraft were assembled at Voronezh in the later 1970s in anticipation of successful certification. The first (flown on October 25th, 1977) was built largely by hand, subsequent machines making increasing use of series production equipment. These early aircraft were used in certification and development flying before handover to Aeroflot[59]. Voronezh factory production engineers conducted a "redesign cycle"[60] of over 50 areas, cutting some 1500kg/3300lb of airframe weight. Production of the Il-86 began in 1976 and continued until 1991. The first two machines were hand-manufactured, in 1976 and 1977 respectively, by Ilyushin at the bureau's own Moscow prototype construction shop; one was used for flight testing and one for static ground testing. Three aircraft were assembled at Voronezh in 1979: one by hand and two using series manufacturing techniques. Subsequent years' manufacturing totals were: 1980, one; 1981, nil; 1982, 11; 1983, 12; 1984, 8; 1985, 9; 1986, 11; 1987, 10; 1988, 10; 1989, 9; 1990, 11 (including the three for export to China), 1991, 3. Of the 106 examples built, one never flew (being used for static tests) and three were exported.[61]. ServiceAn inaugural flight from Moscow to Tashkent was made on December 26th, 1980 but services-proper commenced after 1 February 1981. Aeroflot first operated the Il-86 on peak domestic routes. Foreign services began in June 1981 to Eastern Europe and larger Western European cities. Crewing: In 1987 Radio Moscow reported that Aeroflot "resisted the change" to a three-person crew[62][63]. Vul'fov, A, ibid., reports that the type continued to be operated by four-member crews. Navigators, occupying the observer seat (devoid of any instrumentation), had to stand unsecured on the final approach in order to observe the pilots’ instruments and to read-out indications, despite voice synthesisers being fitted. Soviet operations of the Tu-154 airliner similarly employed four or even five flightdeck crew members, despite foreign operators of that type using three-person flightdeck crews. Long range use: From 1982 Aeroflot put the Il-86 into scheduled service from Moscow to Havana via Shannon and Gander, "perhaps with limited payload or with additional tankerage"[64]. Other scheduled long range services flown by the type were to Buenos Aires, Montevideo and Lima and to Rio de Janeiro and Sao Paulo via Sal Island. Post-Soviet career: After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, local airlines emerged in the 15 successor republics. Il-86s serving with Aeroflot administrations ("Directorates") in these nations accrued to their airlines and many were leased or sold. From April 2002, the European Union, the USA and much of the rest of the world banned noisier aircraft, including the Il-86. By 2008, the type operated solely within the former USSR. In May 2007, 42 Ilyushin Il-86s remained in service. On October 23rd, 2006, Aeroflot Deputy Director General Igor Desyatnichenko said: "the Il-86 will be withdrawn from service starting November 15 as it is too costly to maintain through the winter and to operate for just two or three months in the summer"[65]. Passenger and luggage handling: The Il-86's carry-on luggage arrangements were rarely used[66]. Vul'fov (ibid.) notes: "Thank God no civil servant got it into his head to refuse the parallel opportunity offered to passengers of electing to drop their luggage when checking-in at airports. Otherwise, the loading of luggage into the aircraft by passengers would have turned into a proper nightmare lasting hours." The three integral airstairs are used regularly for disembarkation and boarding when the aircraft is docked at remote hardstands. Military service: With its built-in stairs and below deck holds, the Il-86 was expected to serve in the Soviet air forces: "The wide-bodied Il-86 can perform not only as a troop transport ... but may also in the future form the basis for a command and control aircraft for airbrne coordination of Warsaw Pact forces"[67]. In the event, four airframes (c/n 042, 043, 046 and 048, carrying quasi-civil registrations SSSR-86046, '7, '8 and '9) were delivered to the 8th Special Purposes Aviation Division at the Chkalovsky air base near Moscow. These were designated Il-80, Il-87 or Il-86VKP (Russian: “ВКП” for “воздушный коммандный пост”; transliterated: "vozdushniy kommandnyi post" “veh-kah-peh” and meaning "aerial command post"). One airframe was reportedly refitted as transport for the President of Russia. The Il-80/Il-86VKP has the NATO reporting name Camber: the same as the passenger Il-86.
An Il-86 of Aeroflot
OperatorsCivil operators In May 2007, 37 of 106 Il-86s remained in service with: [68]
Military operators In May 2007, two of 4 Il-86VKPs (Il-80s; Il-87s) remained in service with:[68] Former operators of the Il-86VKP (or Il-80; or Il-87) include:[69] Specifications
IncidentsThe Il-86 is seen as one of the world's safest airliners. Only one accident involving fatalities had taken place by 2008. A 2006 ICAO paper stated: "There were no fatal accidents in passenger-carrying operations involving a wide-body IL-86, for all periods of operation"[76]. The first deputy minister of transport of Russia and head of the State Civil Aviation Service Aleksandr Nyeradko said in 2003: "the Il-86 was and remains one of the world's most dependable airliners[77]. The following are all significant recorded safety events in the history of the Il-86 to date:-
Following the Moscow crash in July 2002, the MAK Interstate Aviation Committee withdrew the Il-86's certificate of airworthiness, temporarily grounding the type. The certificate was rapidly restored in stages, the process being complete by early 2003[85]. The accident prompted the Egyptian civil aviation authorities to state that they intended to ban Il-86 operations to Egypt on safety grounds. Amid continuing negotiations, by 2007 the intention appeared to have lapsed and intensive Il-86 operations to and from that country continued in 2008[86]. See alsoWikimedia Commons has media related to:
Comparable aircraft Related lists References
| | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||