V and set theoryIf ω is the set of natural numbers, then Vω is the set of hereditarily finite sets, which is a model of set theory without the axiom of infinity. Vω+ω is the universe of "ordinary mathematics", which is a model of Zermelo set theory. If κ is an inaccessible cardinal, then Vκ is a model of Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory itself, and Vκ+1 is a model of Morse–Kelley set theory. V is not "the set of all sets". Note that every individual stage Vα is a set, but their union V is a proper class. The sets in V are called hereditarily well-founded sets; the axiom of foundation (or regularity) demands that every set is well founded and hence hereditarily well-founded. (Other axiom systems, omitting the axiom of foundation, or replacing it by a strong negation, such as Aczel's anti-foundation axiom, are possible, but rarely used.) Given any set A, the smallest ordinal number α such that A is a subset of Vα is the rank (or hereditary rank) of A. Philosophical perspectivesThere are two distinct approaches to understanding the relationship of the von Neumann universe V to ZFC (and many variations of each approach, and shadings between them). Roughly, formalists will tend to view V as something that flows from the ZFC axioms (for example, ZFC proves that every set is in V). On the other hand, realists are more likely to see the von Neumann hierarchy as something directly accessible to the intuition, and the axioms of ZFC as propositions for whose truth in V we can give direct intuitive arguments in natural language. A possible middle position is that the mental picture of the von Neumann hierarchy provides the ZFC axioms with a motivation (so that they are not arbitrary), but does not necessarily describe objects with real existence. See alsoReferences
| |