Battle of Krasnoi

The Battle of Krasnoi (Krasny) (November 15 to 18, 1812) was a series of skirmishes fought in the final stage of Napoleon's retreat from Moscow. This encounter was noteworthy because of the heavy losses inflicted on the remnants of the Grande Armee by the Russians under General Mikhail Illarionovich Kutuzov. Lacking sufficient artillery, cavalry and supplies to wage battle, Napoleon’s object at Krasnoi was to collect his scattered troops and to resume his retreat. Despite the vast superiority of his forces, Kutusov refrained from launching a full-scale offensive during the four days of fighting.^[1]^[2]^[3]

The climax of the engagement occurred on November 17th, when an aggressive feint by the French Imperial Guard induced Kutusov to delay a potentially decisive final Russian attack. Napoleon was thus able to withdraw part of his army before the Russians seized Krasnoi.

Despite Napoleon's success in saving part of his army from destruction at Krasnoi, overall the encounter was ruinous to the French. During the four days of combat Napoleon’s subordinate commanders suffered heavy defeats in individual actions, and large numbers of French stragglers were captured by the Russians. The Grande Armee was also compelled to abandon much of its remaining artillery and baggage train.

The forces converge on Krasny

Napoleon retreats from Smolensk

After departing from Moscow on October 18 with 100,000 combat ready but undersupplied troops, Napoleon's strategic object was to quarter his army for the winter at the closest French supply depot, which was at Smolensk, 270 miles to the west. During the three week march to Smolensk however the Grande Armee was devastated by a combination of factors: starvation, demoralization, breakdown in troop discipline, a crippling loss of horses and essential supplies, and by attacks from the Russian army and constant harassment by its Cossack irregulars and partisans.^[4]

The condition of the Grande Armee was further devastated by sub-zero temperatures in the first two weeks of November (see "General Winter").^[5]

By the time the French arrived at Smolensk on November 9, the strategic situation in Russia had turned decisively against Napoleon.Only 40% of the Grande Armee was still under arms at this point.^[6] Due to the ravaged condition of his forces and French defeats on other fronts, Napoleon realized his position at Smolensk was untenable, and chose to continue his retreat.^[7] The new strategic goal was to put the Grande Armee into winter quarters further west, in the area of the massive French supply depot of Minsk.^[8]

Having lost contact with Kutusov during the previous two weeks, Napoleon incorrectly believed that the Russian army must have been as devastated by the elements as was his own.^[9] Not expecting an offensive by Kutusov, Napoleon made the strategic mistake of resuming his retreat by dispatching the Grande Armee's corps separately from Smolensk on successive days starting on November 11. Thus the French approached Krasny strung out in a 40 mile long column of disconnected corps, and their troops were not massed together in preparation for battle.^[10]

On November 14, the corps of Poniatowski and Junot, at the helm of the retreating French army, passed through Krasny and continued marching west to Orsha. The next day, November 15, Napoleon himself arrived at Krasny with his 16,000 strong Imperial Guard. There Napoleon planned to remain for several days so that the 6,000 troops of the IV Corps of Eugene, the 9,000 troops of the I Corps of Davout, and the 8,000 troops of the III Corps of Ney could unite with him before he resumed his retreat. Ney's corps formed the rearguard and was not to leave Smolensk until November 17.

Marching in-between and around these French corps were nearly 40,000 troops who had devolved into mobs of unarmed, disorganized stragglers.

Kutusov's southern march

During this same period, the main Russian army under Kutusov followed the French on a parallel southern road. Because this route passed through countryside not yet economically devastated by previous campaigning, the Russian army approached Krasny much less weakened by attrition than was the Grande Armee.^[11]

Based on faulty intelligence reports, Kutusov believed that only one third of the French army was retreating through Krasny toward Orsha, with Napoleon and the balance of his forces marching much further to the north.^[12] Kutusov therefore accepted a plan proposed by his staff officer, Colonel Toll, to march on Krasnoi to destroy what was believed to be an isolated French column.^[13]

The Russian position at Krasny began forming on November 15, when the 3,500 strong flying advance guard of Adam Ozharovsky seized the town. That same day the 17,000 troops of Miloradovich took position alongside the eastern road leading into Krasny from Smolensk. Kutusov himself reached Krasny with the 35,000 strong main army on November 16.

In total, at Krasny Kutusov had 52,000 to 60,000 regular troops at his disposal, including a large cavalry force and approximately 500 cannon. Another 20,000 Cossack irregulars, operating mostly in small bands, supplemented the main army by harassing the French at all points along the forty mile long road from Smolensk to Krasny.

November 15: the rout of Ozharovsky

November 15 saw the first actions in and around Krasny as the 16,000 strong Imperial Guard, led personally by Napoleon, marched past the 17,000 troops of Miloradovich, who were positioned on the high ground parallel to the road. Impressed by order and composure of the elite Guardsmen, Miloradovich decided not to attack them, and settled instead for bombarding the French from afar. The Russian cannonfire did not render much damage to the Guard, which continued moving toward Krasny.^[14]

Also this afternoon, on the road near Nikolino and Yeskovo, the Imperial Guard was harassed by the Cossacks of General Orlov-Denisov. The eyewitness description of this encounter by the Russian partisan leader Denis Davidov, which eloquently portrays the comportment of the Old Guard and Napoleon, has become one of the most quoted in the histories of the 1812 war:

Later that day, Napoleon and his Guard entered Krasny, and his troops chased away the squadrons of Cossacks under Ozharovsky who were in possession of the town.^[16] Napoleon promptly made plans to remain in Krasny for several days so the rest of his army could catch-up with him.

Shortly after midnight that evening, Napoleon detected the campfires of Ozharovsky's 3,500 strong force near Kutkovo, south of Krasny. Recognizing that Ozharovsky's position was dangerously isolated from Kutusov's main army, Napoleon dispatched the Young Guard on a sneak attack against the Russian encampment, which was not protected by pickets. The operation was first entrusted to General Rapp, but at the last moment Napoleon replaced Rapp with General Roguet. Roguet then divided the Guardsmen into three columns and began a silent advance on Ozharovsky's camp. In the ensuing combat, the Russians were taken completely by surprise, and despite resisting fiercely, were totally routed. As many as half of Ozharovsky's troops were killed or captured, and the remainder threw their weapons in a nearby lake and fled south. Lacking cavalry, Roguet was unable to pursue Ozharovsky's remaining troops.^[17]

November 16: the defeat of Eugene

Miloradovich attacks

The next day, November 16, however, went much better for the Russians as Miloradovich's soldiers cut the road leading to Krasny and inflicted heavy losses on the French corps of Prince Eugène de Beauharnais. In this skirmishing, Eugene's IV Corps lost one third of its original force of 6,000, as well as its baggage train and artillery. Eugene was saved from total destruction only because Kutusov, who didn't want the skirmishing to expand into a full scale battle, ordered Miloradovich to restrain himself and reposition his troops closer to the main army at Shilova.^[18] A force of Cossacks was left to harass Eugene while Miloradovich's final attack was postponed to the next day.

Kutusov at Shilova

Earlier that day, Kutusov's main army finally arrived within five miles of Krasny, taking up positions around the villages of Novoselki and Shilova. Kutusov could have attacked Krasny immediately, but he chose not too.

That evening, under pressure from his aggressive subordinate generals to move decisively against the French, Kutusov finally made plans for an offensive, but he firmly forbade his commanders from executing the attack until daylight on November 17, which meant the French would have the entire evening to evacuate Krasny unharrassed by the Russians.

The Russian battle plan called for the army to execute a three pronged attack on Krasny. Miloradovich was to remain east of the town near Yeskovo, and attack Eugene's IV Corps and Davout's I Corps. The main army at Novoselki and Shilova would break into two groups: Prince Golitsyn would advance directly north through Uvarovo against Krasny with 15,000 troops. Alexander Tormasov with 20,000 troops was to encircle Krasny from the west by marching through Kutkovo to Dobroye, where they would cut the French retreat route to Orsha. Ozharovsky's flying column—reinforced since its drubbing by the Young Guard—would operate independently west and north of Krasny.

Sometime after 1:00 AM on November 17, Kutusov learned from prisoners that Napoleon would be remaining in Krasny, and not withdrawing before the Russian attack as Kutusov had expected. Kutusov now had second thoughts about executing the Russian army's planned offensive.^[19]

November 17: The Guard's feint

Davout in danger

At 3:00 AM on November 17, the 9,000 troops of Davout's I Corps decamped from their bivouac near Rzhavka and began a rushed march to Krasny. The reports of Eugene's defeat the previous day were so dismaying that Davout felt it necessary to abandon his original plan of postponing his movement until Ney's III Corps, still at Smolensk, had caught up with him. ^[20]

Miloradovich, permitted by Kutusov to recommence his attack, opened a massive artillery barrage on Davout near Yeskovo. The panicked French troops began fleeing from the road, and as Russian infantry and cavalry attacks were likely to follow, the I Corps was soon threatened with destruction.^[21]

Napoleon's gamble

Davout's peril, and the distressing developments of the previous day had alerted Napoleon to the grave danger confronting the Grande Armée. Waiting for Davout and Ney in Krasny was no longer feasible, given that any kind of determined attack by Kutusov would destroy the Grande Armée. The starving French troops also needed to reach their closest supply source—25 miles west at Orsha—before the Russians captured the town ahead of him.^[22]

At this critical juncture, Napoleon's sense of initiative returned to him for the first time in weeks. In Caulaincourt's words: “This turn of events, which upset all the Emperor's calculations… would have overwhelmed any other general. But the Emperor was stronger than adversity, and became the more stubborn as danger seemed more imminent."^[23]

Immediately, before daylight, Napoleon prepared his Imperial Guard to make an aggressive feint against Miloradovich and the main Russian army, gambling that this unexpected maneuver would discourage the Russians from attacking Davout. The Grande Armée's remaining artillery was massed for combat, and the Guardsmen formed themselves into attack columns.^[24]

Simultaneously, the remnant of Eugene's IV Corps was ordered to advance west from Krasny, to secure the Grande Armée's escape route to Orsha.^[25]

Napoleon's hope was to fend off the Russians just long enough to collect Davout's and Ney's troops, and to immediately resume his retreat before Kutusov attacked or outflanked him by moving on Orsha.^[26]

The Guard advances

At 5:00 AM, 11,000 Imperial Guardsman marched out of Krasny intending to secure the terrain immediately east and southeast of the town.^[27] These troops split into two columns: one 5,000 strong moving along the road to Smolensk, the other 6,000 Young Guardsmen led by Roguet, marching south of the road toward Uvarovo.^[28] The left flank of the Young Guard's column was protected by a battalion of elite Old Guard grenadiers, described by Segur as forming a “fortress like square.”^[29] Stationed on the right of these columns were the weak remnants of the Guard's cavalry.^[30] Overall direction of the operation was entrusted to Marshal Mortier.^[31]

This bold, unexpected feint of the Guard was lent additional melodrama by the personal presence of Napoleon. With his birch bark walking stick in hand, Napoleon placed himself at the helm of his Old Guard grenadiers, declaring “I have played the Emperor long enough! It is time to play general!”^[32]

Facing the tattered but resolute Imperial Guardsmen were densely concentrated Russian infantry columns to the south and east, supported by massive, powerful artillery batteries.

Lacking sufficient cannon of their own, the Guardsmen were badly outgunned by the enemy. As described by Segur: "Russian battalions and batteries barred the horizon on all three sides—in front, on our right, and behind us"^[33]

Kutusov's reaction to the Imperial Guard's forward movement led to the most decisive and controversial development of the battle: he promptly cancelled his army's planned offensive, even in spite of the Russians' overwhelming superiority in strength.^[34]

For most of the rest of this day, the Russians remained at a safe distance from the Guard, beyond the reach of French muskets and bayonets, and simply blasted the enemy with cannonfire from afar.

Combat near Uvarovo

The limited close quarters combat that did occur on this day unfolded throughout the morning and early afternoon around Uvarovo. The Imperial Guard attacked Uvarovo in order to use the village to cover Davout's retreat into Krasny.

Uvarovo was held by two battalions of Galitzin's infantry, which formed a weak forward outpost in advance of the rest of the Russian army. The Russians were soon driven from Uvarovo, as Kutusov forbade Galitzin from reinforcing his troops. Galitzin reacted by commencing a devastating artillery barrage on Uvarovo, which took a terrible toll on the Young Guardsmen.^[35]

Kutusov, in order to mass as much strength as possible behind Galitzin, at this point ordered Miloradovich to shift his position west, so that it linked with Galitzin's lines.^[36] Kutusov's decision to realign Miloradovich's troops is remarkable, as the bulk of the Russian army—Galitzin's and Tormasov's commands—were already merged in a powerful defensive position. Miloradovich was thus denied the chance to complete the destruction of Davout.

Meanwhile, to the north, Davout's troops began streaming into Krasny, harassed by swarms of Cossacks who made no serious attempt to stop them. The Russian artillery continued to pound Davout's corps with grapeshot, inflicting ruinous casualties on the I Corps. Most of Davout's baggage train was lost, but a significant number of his infantrymen had been saved, and they were rallied by their officers in Krasny.^[37]

Next, General Bennigsen, second in seniority only to Kutusov among Russian generals, ordered Galitzin to recapture Uvarovo. Galitzin's attack was met by a simultaneous counterattack by a column of the Guard's voltigeurs.^[38]

Galitzin attacked the voltigeurs with two regiments of cuirassiers; the French formed squares and repelled the attack. A third Russian attack, however, punctured the French square, and soon the entire contingent of Guardsmen was killed or captured. A second line of French troops, which had been advancing to support the voltigeurs, then fell back under heavy Russian cannonfire.^[39]

Nearby, another skirmish took place, where the Dutch division of the Old Guard was driven from a critical defensive position with massive casualties, due mostly to cannonfire. Roguet attempted to support the Dutch by attacking the Russian artillery batteries with the Guard's 1st Light Infantry, but this offensive was atomized by Russian grapeshot and cavalry charges. Only fifty soldiers and eleven officers in the 1st Light Infantry survived this encounter.^[40]

Napoleon retreats

Around 11:00 AM, as the Imperial Guard was holding firm near Uvarovo despite its withering losses, Napoleon received intelligence reports that Tormasov's troops were readying to march west of Krasny.^[41] This news, coupled with the Young Guard's mounting casualties, forced Napoleon to abandon his ultimate object of standing down Kutusov long enough for Ney's III Corps to arrive in Krasny. If Kutusov opted to attack, the Grande Armée would be encircled and destroyed. Napoleon immediately ordered the Old Guard to fall back on Krasny, and then join Eugene's IV Corps in marching west toward Liady and Orsha. The Young Guard, nearing its breaking point, would remain near Uvarovo, to be relieved shortly thereafter by Davout's reorganized troops from Krasny.

Napoleon's decision was not an easy one to make. Segur describes the beleaguered Emperor's predicament as follows:

In short order, the Old Guard was following the IV Corps moving west out of Krasny, and the road to Orsha was clogged with soldiers and their wagonry. Huge mobs of civilians, fugitives, and stragglers preceded the retreating French troops.^[43]

Meanwhile, near Uvarovo the Young Guard's capacity to resist the Russians was deteriorating rapidly, and Mortier ordered a retreat before his remaining troops were surrounded and destroyed. As if on parade ground drill, the perfectly disciplined Guardsmen then turned about face and marched back to Krasny, absorbing a final, terrible barrage of Russian cannonshot as they retired.^[44]

Only 3,000 of the Young Guard's original 6,000 troops had survived the Russian shelling near Uvarovo. November 17 may have been the bloodiest day in the Young Guard's entire history.

The Young Guard's retreat did not end once it returned to Krasny. Mortier and Davout were so wary of the possibility that the inert Kutusov might attack that they immediately joined the throng of troops, mobs and wagons rushing that moment to Liady. Only a weak rearguard under General Friedrich was left to hold Krasny.

Ney's III Corps, having departed Smolensk only that morning, would not find Davout's I Corps in Krasny awaiting him.

Kutusov delays the pursuit

Miloradovich and Galitzin were not permitted by Kutusov to attack Krasny for several more hours.^[45]

At 2:00 PM, satisfied that the French were in full retreat and not intending to resist his troops' advance, Kutusov finally allowed Tormasov to begin his enveloping movement west through Kutkovo and north to Dobroye. It would take Tormasov two hours to reach his destination, however, by which time the opportunity to encircle and destroy the Grande Armée would be passed.^[46]

Sometime around 3:00 PM, Galitzin's troops rushed into Krasny like a torrent, and Friedrich's rearguard quickly crumbled.

Simultaneously, on the western road to Liady, the French initially encountered an ambush by the small detachments of Ozharovsky and Rosen. A bedlam of exploding grapeshot, overturned wagons, careening carriages, and mobs of fugitives rushing in panic ensued. But the troops of Cobert and Latour-Maubourg forced the Russians aside, and Napoleon was finally marching on Orsha.^[47]

The final noteworthy event of the day occurred in Dobroye, when the hind end of the I Corps baggage train, including Davout's personal carriages, fell to the Cossacks. Among the booty captured by the Russians were Davout's war chest, a plethora of maps of the Middle East, Central Asia and India, and Davout's Marshal's baton.^[48]

By nightfall on November 17, Kutusov had occupied Krasny and its surroundings with his 70,000 troops. Marshal Ney, still advancing on Krasny from the east, was not yet aware the Grande Armée was no longer in Krasny to receive his III Corps.

November 18: the destruction of Ney

At 3:00 PM on November 18, Ney's III Corps finally made contact with Miloradovich, who had posted 12,000 troops on a hill overlooking a deep ravine.^[49] Ney had 8,000 combatants and 7,000 stragglers under his command at this point.^[50]

Believing that Davout was still in Krasny, directly behind Miloradovich’s columns, Ney turned down a Russian offer of honorable surrender, and boldy attempted to ram his way through the enemy. The dogged French troops then succeeded in piercing the first two lines of Russian infantry.^[51] The third line, however, proved indominatable, and at the decisive moment, the Russians counterattacked. An eyewitness to this engagement, the English General Sir Robert Wilson, describes it thusly:

The terrible defeat of the III Corps was thorough enough to induce the chivalrous Miloradovich to extend another honorable surrender to Ney. Again, Ney refused to submit, and with 2,000 refugees—all that remained of his corps—he absconded into the forests pursued by Platov's Cossacks.

For the next two days Ney's small party bravely stood off Cossack attacks as it marched westward via footpaths in search of Napoleon's army. The elements and the Cossacks soon reduced Ney's contingent to only 800 diehards. On November 20, Ney and Napoleon were reunited near Orsha, an event which the demoralized French troops regarded as the emotional equivalent of a great victory.^[53]

At Krasny, Ney's steely courage in defeat immortalized him in the annals of military history, leading Napoleon to bestow upon him the sobriquet of "Bravest of the Brave."

Summary of results

Total French losses in the Krasny skirmishes are estimated between 6,000 and 13,000 killed and wounded, with another 20,000 to 26,000 lost as prisoners to the Russians. One notable prisoner was Jean Victor Poncelet, the future inventor of projective geometry. Almost all of the French prisoners were stragglers. The French also lost close to 200 artillery pieces and a huge portion of their supply train. Russian losses are estimated to have been no more than 5,000 killed and wounded.

Significant however was that Napoleon successfully led 75% of the combatants of the I and IV Corps and the Imperial Guard out of Krasny, thus salvaging his hope of using these troops as a nucleus around which he could rebuild his army the following year.

Krasny was a Russian victory, but a highly unsatisfactory one. Tsar Alexander I was enraged with Kutusov upon learning of the old field marshal's failure to totally destroy the French. Nonetheless, owing to Kutusov's immense popularity with the Russian aristocracy, Alexander gave him the victory title of Prince of Smolensk for what had been accomplished in this battle.

Notes

^ Krasnoi is summarized in constrasting ways in the historical literature. The latest accounts of the affair (Riehn, Cate, and Smith) regard it as an incomplete Russian victory over the Grande Armee. Older, more traditional texts (Chandler, et al) summarize the event solely as the Imperial Guard’s action on November 17th, calling the encounter a French victory, and even going so far as to suggest that a major combat occurred accompanied by a Russian retreat. The older texts seem to be propagating a myth, as on Nov. 17th the Guard barely made contact with the Russians and at no point did Kutusov retreat.
^ Chandler, page 828: "The Russians, meanwhile, seemed in little hurry to get to serious grips with their adversaries. A great deal of skirmishing and minor actions took place at various points along the road, but nothing really serious happened until the 17th. By that date Napoleon had been at Krasnoe for two days, waiting for his extended column to close up. He was not altogether satisfied with the situation, however, as is shown by the dispatch of two regiments of the Young Guard to aid Eugene's IVth Corps, which was held up by Davidovitch at Nikulina for much of the 16th before finding a way round the block through Jomina. Indeed, his anxiety to ensure that the main road should remain open induced Napoleon to order an attack against Kutusov by the Guard on the morning of the 17th. At first he thought to entrust this operation to General Rapp, but then changed his mind and placed General Roguet of the Middle Guard in command. The operation was a complete success. The southbound French columns (16,000 strong) caught Kutusov completely unawares, so accustomed had he become to the idea of a passive French opponent. The Russian partisan leader, Davydov, fancifully recorded that "The Guard with Napoleon passed through our Cossacks like a hundred-gun ship through a fishing fleet," and in no time the Russian commander in chief was ordering his 35,000 men to retreat south. The Russians subsequently tried to misrepresent the outcome of the action, claiming that "Bonaparte commanded in person and made the most vigorous exertions, but in vain; he was obliged to flee the field of battle." But this was flagrant propaganda. It was Kutusov who had very much the worst of the encounter."
^ Smith, pages 201-203. "The 2nd clash at Krasnoi, 14-18 November - A village in the central sector, 40 km south west of Smolensk. A victory for the Russians under General Miloradovich (III,V,VI,VII and VIII Corps of Kutusov's army), over the remnants of the Grande Armee under Napoleon. This four day action saw the remnants of the Grande Armee, some 50,000 men in all, strung out of a column four days long, hurry their way past the 90,000 Russians. The Russians claimed 13,000 killed, 26,500 captured, 133 guns and fifteen colours, standards and eagles taken, as well as Marshal Davout's baton. No serious effort was made to stop the fugitives; Kutuzov could have annihilated Napoleon here. For some reason he let most of them go."
^ The Grande Armee’s implosion during the first stage of the retreat is summarized by Chandler (page 823); Riehn (pages 322, 335-337, and 341); Cate (pages 343 – 347); and Zamoyski (377-385).
^ Cate, pages 353 – 354, describes the devastating effects of frost on the Grande Armee at this time, including the estimation by a French memoirist that nearly 10,000 men and horses froze to death on the night of November 8th/9th alone.
^ Riehn, pages 343 - 345
^ Napoleon’s northern flank began collapsing as a result of Russian victories at the Second Battle of Polotsk (Oct. 18-20) and the Battle of Czasniki (Oct. 31), and the surrender of the massive French supply depot at Vitebsk (Nov. 7). Napoleon’s operations to the south, which were guarded by the Austrian army in Volhynia, were compromised by a series of Russian maneuvers (Sept. 21 – Oct. 11) that forced the heavily outnumbered Austrians to retreat into Poland without offering battle. This operational success enabled a sizeable force of Russians under Chicagov to begin an offensive (Oct. 29) in the other direction – back to the east – to threaten Napoleon’s planned line of retreat near Minsk. In the Grande Armee’s main operational theater near Smolensk, a French defeat at Liakhovo (Nov. 9) resulted in the en masse surrender of Augereau’s brigade to the Russians, while Platov’s Cossacks inflicted heavy losses on Eugene’s corps near Dukovtshina (Nov. 9 – 10). Meanwhile, Cossack raids into Poland revealed widespread demoralization among the Poles, who were among Napoleon’s most important allies
^ Riehn, page 349. Note that on Nov. 17th the Franco-Polish garrison at Minsk surrendered to the Russians, which was another huge strategic and logistical disaster for Napoleon.
^ Riehn, pages 349 – 350
^ Riehn, pages 350 –351, discusses the Grande Armee’s order of march at this juncture and summarizes it as “an open invitation to disaster.”
^ Parkinson, page 213 - 214
^ Riehn, page 351. Amazingly, in spite of the Cossacks’ near unchallenged command of countryside and roads, intelligence reporting to Russian headquarters was poor.
^ Riehn, page 351
^ Riehn, page 352
^ Davidov, pages 142-143. Note that Chandler, Nicolson, and Napoleon's biographer Felix Markham incorrectly state that Davidov was referring to the Guard's skirmishing at Uvarovo on November 17. But Davidov's memoirs are highly specific regarding the date, time, and location of this occurrence; there should be no doubt that it happened on the afternoon of November 15 on the road near Nikolino and Yeskovo.
^ Cate, page 358
^ Cate (page 359); Segur (pages 199 – 201). Note that David Chandler and many other historians confuse this nightfall attack by the Young Guard against Ozharovsky on Nov. 15th/16th with the Imperial Guard’s feint against the Russian center on the morning of Nov. 17th. Chandler, et al, are very deeply in error on this count.
^ Wilson, page 269. Russians and French alike found Kutusov's order to be stunning.
^ Riehn, page 352
^ Wilson, page 269
^ Beskrovny L.G, Zhilin and Tarle
^ Caulaincourt, page 219
^ Caulaincourt, page 219
^ Caulaincourt, page 220
^ Cate, page 360
^ Caulaincourt, page 220
^ Note that the details of the Guards' troop composition, exact number of soldiers, high command, and exact direction of movement on this morning are superficially or confusingly described by most texts. The most up-to-date sources are from Zamoyski, Riehn, and Cate, and although these authors' narratives are excellent and factually reliable, they do not address this action comprehensively. Segur's description is richly detailed and probably veritable, but disjointed as a whole. The descriptions of this operation rendered by Chandler, Palmer, and Nicolson are contradictory, confusing, contain glaring factual errors, and should not be trusted by the reader
^ Segur, page 202, and Zamoyski, map on page 423
^ Segur, page 202
^ Segur, page 202
^ Cate, page 360 and Segur, page 202. Again, the sources are contradictory on Mortier's exact status in the attack, but Cate describes him as the commander of the Young Guard, and Segur refers to the overall operation sometimes by referring simply to it as "Mortier."
^ Cate, page 360; Segur, page 202
^ Segur, page 202
^ See Riehn, pages 351-358, Cate, pages 358-361, and Wilson, pages 270-277, Tarle, pages 364-368, and Parkinson, pages 214-217 for eloquent, informative discussions of Kutusov's comportment at Krasny. Kutusov's possible motives for restraining his army at Krasny have been debated by historians for two centuries. The issue is especially inscrutable because of the Russian commander's personality: he was more intelligent than most of his peers, and his manipulative, Machiavellian dealings in Russian military, social and political circles were well known. Some historians argue that Kutusov wanted Napoleon to survive in order to counterbalance England's dominance of international affairs, others argue that he did not want to jeopardize his place in posterity by risking open combat with Napoleon. Other explanations focus on Kutusov's advanced age—67 years old—his ill health and the fact that he was nearing death. Kutusov's proponents argue that he may have rightly reasoned that the Russian army's combat capability at Krasny was not as formidable as was believed by other Russian generals and historians.
^ Wilson, page 270
^ Wilson, page 270
^ Cate, page 361
^ Wilson, page 270
^ Wilson, page 270
^ Segur, page 205
^ The sources are unclear as to when exactly Napoleon received these reports, and what specifically the reports indicated. Wilson, page 273, indicates that Tormasov was not dispatched west until 2:00 PM, well after Napoleon began his retreat from Uvarovo and Krasny. Prior to this, the only Russians active west of Krasny were Ozharovsky's skirmishers.
^ Segur, page 204
^ Zamoyski, page 422-423
^ Segur, page 205. The sources conflict as to exactly what time Mortier began his withdrawal. Segur says 2:00 PM, but Riehn suggests it must have started several hours earlier
^ The sources conflict as to when the Russians advanced on Krasny. Riehn, page 355, claims Miloradovich was not allowed to pursue the Young Guard until around 12:00 PM, and that not until 3:00 PM did his troops attack Friedrich in the town. Segur claims the Young Guard did not begin withdrawing until 2:00 PM.
^ Wilson, page 273
^ Wilson, page 273-274
^ Wilson, page 274. Other sources state that Davout's baggage was captured earlier that day east of Krasny, or the previous day during the fighting with Eugene near Eskovo. Wilson's narrative seems most credible.
^ Wilson, page 278
^ Riehn, page 355
^ Cate page 361
^ Wilson, page 278
^ Chandler, page 830

Contents